Rivals clash on oil industry plans

Rivals clash on oil industry plans

David Cameron is to hold a Cabinet meeting in north-east Scotland ahead of the country's September referendum on independence.

Prime Minister David Cameron during a meeting of his Cabinet at the Shell UK offices in Aberdeen

Prime Minister David Cameron during a visit to the BP Etap platform (Eastern Trough Area Project) in the North Sea, around 100 miles east of Aberdeen

First Minister Alex Salmond arrives at a meeting of the Scottish Cabinet at Portlethen Parish Church near Aberdeen

David Cameron, left, talks with workers during a visit to the BP Etap platform in the North Sea

Satirical artist Kaya Mar carries one of his paintings depicting Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond with a petrol pump through Westminster

Mr Cameron was shown details of the platform's work and location during a tour of the rig

The BP Etap platform which Mr Cameron visited lies around 100 miles east of Aberdeen

First published in National News © by

The North Sea oil and gas industry is better supported by the "deep pockets" and "broad shoulders" of the UK economy than it would be if Scotland was independent, the Prime Minister has said.

David Cameron made the claim as he clashed with Scottish First Minister Alex Salmond over the future of the sector when the two lead ers held rival cabinet meetings just a few miles from each other in the north east of Scotland.

Mr Cameron went on the attack in the independence debate by gathering his top team north of the border in Aberdeen and warning that leaving the UK would harm the key sector.

The Scottish and UK cabinet meetings were held as retired oil executive Sir Ian Wood published a report calling for measures to generate £200 billion for the British economy by ensuring up to four billion extra barrels are recovered from the North Sea over the next 20 years.

The P rime Minister backed that report as he insisted t he oil and gas sector is better supported by the UK than it would be in an independent Scotland.

He said: "It's more important than ever that the North Sea oil and gas industry has the backing of the whole of the United Kingdom, it has the deep pockets and the broad shoulders of the UK economy to make sure there are the tax allowances, the solidity, the investment, to make sure we can go on benefiting from this for many years to come.

"Scotland has done well out of the North Sea and the United Kingdom has done well out of the North Sea. It has been an international success story.

"Now. as we get to the later stages of the North Sea, long-term investment, deep pockets from the UK Government is going to be really important to recover that oil and gas."

He rejected suggestions that Scotland or the UK should have set up a Norway-style oil fund to save for the future.

"We see that North Sea revenues have built schools and hospitals and roads and railways," he said.

"Here in Scotland they've sustained a level of spending per head that is ahead of that of the rest of the United Kingdom."

But Mr Salmond, speaking after the Scottish cabinet met in nearby Portlethen, highlighted Norway as an example of a small country with a successful oil industry.

The Scottish First Minister said: "We are told today that North Sea oil and gas is better handled by a big country like Britain as opposed to a small country like Scotland.

''That's a very interesting concept for people in this part of the country, who can glance across the North Sea to Norway, a country smaller than Scotland but a country which by every observation has handled its oil and gas resources better than the stewardship of Westminster.

''I don't mean better just for the companies earning profits and investment, that's important, and not even just for the workforce terms, conditions and safety, which is hugely important.

''I mean handling the oil and gas resource for the community as a whole as Norway has accumulated much of its revenues for a futures fund for future generations.''

The Scottish Government has put forward plans to establish two separate oil funds if there is a Yes vote in September's referendum - one short-term fund to help deal with fluctuations in oil and gas revenues, alongside a long-term savings fund.

But the Prime Minister claimed Mr Salmond "underplays the risks" of independence.

"This family of nations is better off together, not just that Scotland is better off in the United Kingdom but we in the rest of the United Kingdom think that we are better off with Scotland - that we want you to stay," he said.

"My argument is one that is unremittingly positive about the success of this family of nations and we should keep the family together."

The Prime Minister again refused to entertain calls for him to go head to head with Mr Salmond in a televised debate on the referendum.

"The debate that needs to take place is the debate in Scotland between people of differing views," he said.

Downing Street said tax revenues from oil and gas in 2012-13 were £4.7 billion lower than the previous year - a drop of more than 40% and a sum it says equates to more than a third of Scotland's health budget or two-thirds of its spending on education.

Before chairing the UK cabinet meeting in Aberdeen, Mr Cameron toured a BP installation 150 miles (240km) east of the city and argued that Scotland alone would find it harder to invest and deal with oil market volatility.

"Because we are a top 10 economy we can afford the tax allowances, the investment, the long-term structure that is necessary to make sure we recover as much from the North Sea as possible," he said.

However, Mr Salmond claimed the " massive investment" currently going into the North Sea could have occurred earlier "if it hadn't been for George Osborne's number of tax changes that caused uncertainty".

He said: " We've had 16 tax changes in the North Sea in 10 years, we've had 14 oil ministers in the last 17 years, three in the last four years, one thing that Scottish control of oil and gas resources will offer is a much more stable, long term policy."

Mr Salmond has promised to base part of the Scottish energy ministry in Aberdeen if there is a Yes vote on September 18.

Mr Cameron, who toured an oil instillation before the cabinet meeting, defended his approach to the independence debate.

His opponents have criticised him for sending ministers north for fleeting visits.

Asked if he should speak more to the public in person, he told STV: "Every time I come to Scotland I have a range of different meetings."

He also defended the UK Government's decision to rule out allowing a currency union with an independent Scotland.

Chancellor George Osborne rejected the SNP proposal during a whistle-stop visit to Edinburgh earlier this month.

"It would be an extraordinary referendum campaign if the Scottish people weren't told in advance of that referendum what the consequences of separation are," he told the broadcaster.

"There are risks to separation, and it's right that those are properly, calmly and reasonable laid out. That's exactly what has been happening."

Mr Cameron was asked whether he would support an application by an independent Scotland to join the European Union in the event of a Yes vote.

He told the broadcaster: "Absolutely, but it's not my choice about how EU applications work.

"What I have to deal with, what everyone has to deal with, is the realities of the application process to the EU.

"I'm not in charge of that but the head of the Commission has made very clear that there wouldn't be an automatic ability for Scotland to join the EU. That is an important fact for people to take into account."

Responding to the comments, Deputy First Minister Nicola Sturgeon said: "This concession clearly shows that, when pushed under questioning, the Prime Minister climbs down from a position of scaremongering to a position of common sense.

"He would support Scotland's membership of the EU, just as when it comes to it, he will back the continuing sharing of currency."

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree